Where ambitious young professionals connect and grow

Already a member?

Click here to login

Welcome to Brazen Careerist!

Emily Ma is using Brazen Careerist to share ideas. Join now to become a member and start networking with Emily Ma and other professionals just like you. Learn more.

  
Posted On 10.06.09

Ryan and I recently celebrated one year of dating officially. What makes this more impressive is that we’re both extremely career-oriented. Even more extraordinary is the fact that we’re not married with babies.

There’s a lot of pressure to settle down, never mind the fact that I don’t feel anywhere near ready to have children. And while I can imagine my life with Ryan, I don’t see the rush. With previous boyfriends, things could have ended at any moment. Now I have time.

In the Midwest, however, I do not. Twenty-six years of age is starting to get old and the female role models to dispel such rumors are few and far between. I can’t, in fact, think of a single woman in Madison that I look up to and follow for her career. Perhaps because the women I know in leadership roles exemplify negative stereotypes, and perhaps because there are simply more men than women leading business here.

It’s difficult, yes. When I graduated college and entered the real world, I had no idea how difficult it would be. Even in the start-up world, women are barely a consideration. When it comes to founding successful companies, apparently old guys rule. Young guys have a shot too. But women aren’t even part of the equation.

And while I love my job and am lucky to have been given opportunities I wasn’t afforded in previous positions, the patterns, however unintentional, are still there. It’s predominately male in our office and women are predictably relegated to the customer service and marketing departments.

The same pattern is propagated throughout society. For instance, Nisha Chittal reports on a study from Media Matters for America that shows on average, Sunday Morning show guests are 80 percent male (on shows like Chris Matthews, Fox News Sunday, Face the Nation, and Meet the Press).

And yet women do seem to make great strides career-wise. Ernst & Young went so far as to say that the world needs more female bosses. “Investing in women to drive economic growth is not simply about morality or fairness. It’s about honing a competitive edge,” Ernst & Young chairman and CEO Lou Pagnutti said. “Women have contributed more to global GDP growth than have either new technology or the new giants, China and India.”

But the Midwest seems to be particularly fond of holding onto the old formula of success for women: meet, marry, opt-out. This is purely anecdotal of course. The newest Census study shows it’s actually a myth that privileged, well-educated women are opting-out. Even when broken down by geographic location, the Midwest has drastically more married couples with children and both parents in the labor force, compared to say, California or New York (see page 15 in the report).

Which makes me think we’re not telling the right stories.

I recently broke down to Ryan, “I don’t want to be like the young couples we sit with at weddings or the rich ones we meet at events. Their eyes are so vacant. So disappointed. They’re stunned or seemingly regretful. It scares me.”

“Rebecca,” he replied, “do you think we’re anything like those couples?”

I sniffled and agreed, maybe he was right. But I need women to be stronger role models and more outspoken – whatever path they choose. I don’t want to be afraid of motherhood. And I don’t want to be afraid of missed opportunity either.

There are some enthralling stories about the beautiful complexity that is marriage and motherhood. But these stories just don’t exist about being a woman in the workplace. We need to start telling those. Now. Not just recognizing powerful career women, say on a list or with an award, but telling the stories that infuse society. I need to hear more stories with women that inform my consciousness each morning. And I need to hear them right here in Wisconsin.

Share and Enjoy:

Comments

10.07.09

I admire this post. Midwest people that may be operating on a national or contemporary level seem to inevitably clash with the unchanging culture of the midwest.

While I'm not a woman, I have a daughter that I would like to instill and imbue with a strong feminist perspective that she can do anything (career-wise) that she wants to do. My wife still subscribes to the traditional Midwest thinking. It's total culture clash and I'm not sure what to do.

10.07.09

Amen! I'm in Minnesota and have some of the same fears of marrying, having kids, and opt-ing out. Fortunately, I have some great family role-models who have managed to keep a career and have a family throughout their lives, so I know it is possible. The issue is the difference between having a carer and a family and moving up in one's career and having a family. I echo your call: Show me the successful and family-oriented women leaders!

katenonymous
10.07.09

Life is full of missed opportunities. Except for the part where that isn't exactly true. Life is full of choices, which means life is full of opportunity costs. No matter what you decide to do, that decision means you've chosen not to do something else.

That's not bad. That's just the way the world works. Don't fear it; be aware of it, and try to make the choices that you think will be most rewarding to you. You won't always get it right, and that's not bad, either.

Are you sure that those couples are really that disappointed with their lives? Or are you just projecting, because you don't personally want that life?

10.07.09

@ Ryan C - Interesting to hear a guy's perspective, especially such a complex one. Good to hear that you want your daughter to be able to do anything she wants. Thanks so much for sharing.

@ Amanda - Thanks for letting me know your in the same boat. It's always good to hear and hopefully by talking about it more, the successful women will want to speak up more.

@ Kate - Yes, life is full of choices, but the point more is that society, particularly in the Midwest, wants - no, expects - certain behaviors and actions out of each gender. And while you're young and impressionable, this is tough.

katenonymous
10.07.09

So why do you continue to live there? That's a serious question. If it doesn't suit you, why not go somewhere else?

Either say "screw it," and be the role model that you want to find, or say "screw it," and leave.

10.07.09

Kate, I never said the Midwest didn't suit me - I love it, in fact. The weaknesses are often the strengths on the other side of the coin. Nor did I say I wasn't trying to be the role model I wanted to find. It's important to talk about issues, even if you're already taking action. In fact, that's a great first step.

10.07.09

This might be a bit off-topic, but I never understand how people can just "decide" it's time to get married.

I mean, you get married when you fall in love with someone and realize that you want to spend the rest of your life with them.

So it's wrong of people to wonder why others haven't settled down. People get married when they meet the right person, not because they feel 'it's time'.

10.07.09

@Scott, that's a valid point. I see a lot of problems cropping up from people out on a mission to rope someone down and marry them just for the sake of their idea of fulfillment. Some of these things just happen... anyone agree or disagree?

10.07.09

@ Scott - I disagree. I think I've met the right person, but I don't believe it's the right time to get married. So in my case, when I get married, it will be because I believe I've found the right person, but also because I believe it's the right time. Regardless, the jist of your comment I agree with - to each his own, right? :)

10.07.09

Rebecca,
I think you're trying to hard to find what YOU want in other people, and are trying to oblige someone into being your role model. It also sounds like you are blaming prior generations for not making your choices easier to make. I don't understand this attitude and I think that our prior generations have made huge strides that seem to have gone unrecognized by you.

As a very happy and fulfilled, child-free, married business owner, I have to constantly deal with quiet judgments from other women who have opted-out. So what? I don't give it a second thought.

Here's the thing: I always knew what I wanted in my marriage and career, but I never had a female role model either. It never crossed my mind to seek out a role model; perhaps that's a generational thing. I bristled when read, "I need women to be stronger role models". Seriously? Maybe they’re busy doing other things, such as LIVING THEIR OWN LIVES. You don’t need a mentor or a role model as long as YOUR choices make you happy.

10.07.09

@ Lauren - I have huge respect for prior generations and I would hate for there to be any misunderstanding about that. It's great that you're doing well and have not hit any roadblocks - why don't you share your story? Many women aren't so lucky. It would be quite a shame - and slightly ridiculous - if everyone kept their experiences to themselves.

katenonymous
10.07.09

@Rebecca, I don't see where Lauren says she hasn't encountered any roadblocks. But I think, based on her comment, that she might agree with me that the key to having the life you want is to go out and live it. Your post just sounds like a complaint about Midwestern societal expectations. There's nothing in there that tells me you like the region you're in (great if you do, but why don't you mention that as well?).

You're probably not going to change the Midwest, because you just don't have that kind of control over other people. But you can change what you're doing. That is under your control.

10.07.09

@ Kate - Agreed. Did I say anywhere in my post that I wasn't living the life I want? Sheesh. My post is DEFINITELY a complaint about Midwest societal expectations. A huge one. And one I wanted to highlight in hopes that it could change. That's part of me living the life I want - spreading the word on issues I think are important.

FYI, the links under Madison and Wisconsin in my post link to my "I love where I live," post so take a peek. You can't dump everything in one post.

10.07.09

Don't get me wrong, I've hit PLENTY of roadblocks; most of them caused my own actions. I fix them and move on...I don't dwell.

The Cliff Notes version of my story: I wanted out of corporate America so I learned how to manage from my best and worst managers. I married a man who was 100% supportive of all my goals and dreams, as I am for him. A few weeks after (and because of) Sept. 11, 2001, I quit my comfy corporate job and started my own business, making a lot of mistakes along the way - but also doing a lot of great things, too. Now I have a great team of experts that work with me and I make a good living from doing what I love. It's been 8 years and my parent are still waiting for me to get a 'real' job, because that's all they know. When it comes to women in business (and resume writing), I have a 'No Wimps Allowed' attitude and that pushes me on every day. That's it. If you want me to fill in the details, you'll have to take me out for coffee. I like getting out of the office once in a while.

10.07.09

Rebecca,
I've lived in Milwaukee my entire life (except a stint elsewhere for college) and I disagree entirely with your statement about Midwest societal expectations. I don't know where you're searching for role models or what exactly you want out of these role models, but I personally know many Wisconsin women who are both incredibly successful in the corporate world while being family oriented and successfully raising children. I also don't see my peers marrying and "opting-out" of their careers.

Both men and women make choices regarding if/when to start a family and how to raise their children; many women stay home, not because they're "opting out" and missing opportunities, but because they feel strongly that it's the best decision for their family. It's a personal decision; one that is neither right nor wrong. This is the case everywhere, not just the Midwest; I think it's unfair to state that the Midwest isn't keeping up with the rest of the country simply because you haven't found a successful business and family woman to be your role model in Wisconsin.

10.07.09

@ Erin - I agree that opting out isn't about missing opportunities or that it's either right or wrong; it's a purely personal decision just like the decision other moms make to go back to work.

I'm not searching for role models in the literal sense. I do know a large portion of the C-level women in Madison as a result of my last position.

But I do think there need to be more stories spread about these women that you're talking about. Part of the point of the post is that you're exactly right - these women do exist - and the research I used to illustrate my point shows it!

But their stories aren't being told. Go look at my original post on my blog and read through the comments of the many women who relate. I'm so glad that you know of some great women; let's talk about not how they exist (which we totally agree on), but spread the stories of their lives so their contributions can make a greater impact.

katenonymous
10.07.09

@Rebecca, I'm not going to click on 16 links to see if you have a post that says that you like Madison. I'm just not. I have too many other things to do. So there are things you really like about it, but there are some major issues, like the one you talk about here. Why not include that more explicitly in your post? Particularly since the links you mentioned go to a post with a title and URL that don't indicate that?

So you're not really looking for role models after all, you want stories told about those role models. Why not say that the first time? And why not use your blog to tell their stories? If you already know so many of these women, might some of them be interested participating in that?

10.07.09

Kate - Exaggerate much? 1 link is not 16. If you can't find the link under the word "Wisconsin" or "Madison" in my post here it is. And the title of that post is "The Power of Place" - not sure how much clearer I could have made that.

As far as the rest of your questions, we're just going around in a circle. I've never had you agree with one of my posts and am frankly tired of your constant accusatory tone. There's a difference between disagreeing and being a bully. If you have so many other things to do, then stop commenting.

10.07.09

This post has all the hallmarks of Rebecca. :)

"... one year of dating officially." - I can't help but think Ryan has this date somewhere on a spreadsheet.

The essence of this post and the sentence I thought needed to be highlighted - "Which makes me think we’re not telling the right stories."
The news about the newest Census study will eventually become more common news but I think it's going to take some more time ... which is why you wrote this post ... right?

katenonymous
10.07.09

Oh, I see. There are 16 links to the same post. Why is that better?

I'd like to see you own up to what you post, and what it means--and based on other comments, I may not be alone in that. But if you're not going to, then you're not.

10.07.09

Mark - Yes, I too think that's the essence. And I hope that we use facts to challenge what our existing paradigms are, which is a big reason I pointed out the census data as well. Thank you for pointing both of those items out.

Kate - What? There are two links to the same post, one under "Wisconsin" and one under "Madison" - both places it makes absolute sense. You're misunderstanding and being ridiculous. I will no longer be replying to your comments.

katenonymous
10.07.09

That's fine, but when I look at this post (and I tried more than one browser, to see if it was a browser problem) I see links for the following words and phrases:

Ryan
career-oriented
female role models
in Madison
negative stereotypes
apparently old guys rule
love my job
reports
shows
the world needs more female bosses
it's actually a myth
broken down by geographic location
women to be stronger
more outspoken
a woman in the workplace
in Wisconsin

So I'm seeing 16 links that I would have to read through to figure out that somewhere in there, you like Madison. If that's ridiculous, and I'm misunderstanding, then fine. But maybe we're talking past each other.

10.07.09

I think maybe the title of the post "Career Women need to try harder" automatically made some of us defensive. Because, aren't women already trying hard? Haven't we been trying hard all along?

Women's struggles are not lost on Rebecca. Instead of ripping apart her post, why not assuage her fears and anxieties and give her some encouragement and resources.

Instead of attacking Rebecca because she's expressed what some might deem to be a misguided idea or emotion, maybe we could offer her some resources? Show her where to find what she's looking for if you think she's missing something. Offer to tell her your own story (some of you have). Share someone else's story. How is anyone supposed to get better, learn, etc. if you come at them in a negative way.

@Rebecca-I'm scared, too, about making choices when it comes to motherhood and career. You want to give 100% to children...and to your career. How much of each of us is there to go around?

Men struggle with this as well. How am I going take care of my family, and make it to my son's baseball game?

I think a lot of people are successfully navigating these issues, and when I find some good examples I'll forward them to you.

katenonymous
10.07.09

@Erin, looking back through the exchange there was room for that until the issue of the number of links came up. Yes, I'm the one who brought it up--but the links were already there, and then we got sidelined onto "how many links are there," which clearly wasn't anyone's point starting out.

That meant that we never got answers to some of my other questions about the successful women she does know, and how their stories might be told.

I do recognize my part in how this spiraled downward--but I don't think it's true that my comments were only negative. Challenging, sure.

10.07.09

Snaps to @Erin Murtagh! Thank you for your comment, and I agree, I'd love to hear more success stories, too. I want to succeed, but don't want to be a b*&#$ to do it while balancing some family commitment.

10.07.09

@Katenon-I don't think your comments were purely negative either. I hope you don't think my comment was a veiled attempt to single you out. Also, I think there has got to be a place where women are telling their stories...is there a group right here on Brazen where women are doing that?

@Emily-thanks for the kudos...I hope more women in this community will read this post and will contribute to the post.

I don't have a blog. I think it's really brave that people put ideas, thoughts and emotions out there for the masses and openly invite criticism via a comments section. Especially when the criticism can be so immediate.

katenonymous
10.07.09

@Erin--No problem! I don't know if there's a way to do that, other than groups, and the 140-character limit would seem to be a hindrance there. I hear that they're talking about changing that, though, so if there is room for longer comments and posts, a group might be a way to address that.

10.08.09

Great post, Rebecca! Agreed, we do need to be telling more stories about women in the workplace...women who are both doing well, and that are struggling. I think that's why I like Penelope's blog so much - she shares both triumphs and life struggles that impact our work lives (and as an Xer, I relate to her perspectives on many issues).

I guess I've been lucky, in that my career is in non-profit, where women are in the majority, and men are few. I've worked with amazing women leaders, and some that have been less than great - but the same goes for the men I've worked with. I focus less on the gender of the person and what I can learn from them. But also in the non-profit world, I think we're more accepting of LIFE outside of work, and perhaps share and talk more freely about our personal lives, especially when it may affect work.

10.08.09

Jeepers! :)

Rebecca, I understand and agree with a lot of your post. I kinda felt like I was on an island in my situation in life cause many other people around me were making the opposite of the choices I made. And so I looked around and wondered "Am I missing the boat here? Am I going to continue this life completely rogue, and what does that mean? If "everyone else is doing it" does that mean I am doing something wrong? Am I going to be left behind?"

I have had to work hard to seek out women who made similar choices to tell me about their experiences. And by doing that I learned some of the good and bad choices that can be made. And I've made PLENTY of both! It also taught me to seek out women who made completely opposite choices to tell me about their experiences, to learn from them. I seek out conversations and advice because I LOVE learning new things and building new relationships. It has seldomly ever led me astray, because I never would take anyone's opinion as law and follow the lemmings off the cliff. I apply my own experiences, life circumstances, etc into the CHOICES I make.

I just realized at some point that while I may not want to be "on the boat" I didn't really want to be alone "on the island" either.

10.11.09

@Rebecca - I'm glad you've had the opportunity to meet women who have success stories to share. While sometimes their stories aren't as publicized, I think it's most important that you have personally met women who have set incredible examples. Knowing the women you've met personally is much more powerful than reading a story or hearing a speech about someone you'll never actually meet, and it sounds like you're doing a great job!

Got Something To Say?

Got Something To Say?

You Must Be Logged In To Comment
Not a Member? Brazen Careerist is a career management tool for next-generation professionals. Set up a free account today to comment on this post and start sharing your ideas. Learn more.

Network Roulette

Schedule an Event
entrustet favicon.png

Ask A Citi Recruiter Zone

Q: I'm trying to change careers by leveraging my skills ... (More...)
A: Hi Dean: Tramyra just posted a similar question, and you ... (More...)

Jobs

  • Page 1 of 3
Content Affiliations Associate - 162806
Newark - Amazon
Content Creation Supervisor - 162810
Newark - Amazon
Assistant Audio Mastering Engineer - 162816
Newark - Amazon
Financial Analyst - 162922
Jersey City - Amazon
Account Manager - DEFL117247
Wall Township - Safeway Inc

Employer? Post a job