Where ambitious young professionals connect and grow


Free Brazen Careerist E-book!
  
Posted On 05.04.09


Early Friday morning in Tehran, 23-year-old Delara Darabi was executed in the Rasht prison in Iran for a crime that happened when she was 17. Human rights groups had been protesting and trying to save her from execution for months, since it is a violation of international law to execute anyone for a crime that occurred when they were a minor. Despite the protests, Iranian authorities executed her on Friday with no notice.

What is perhaps the saddest part of her story, however, is that the mainstream, traditional news media did not report the story at all. A Google News search on Delara Darabi revealed, as of late last night, a total of ZERO mainstream US news stories. The only stories about Delara as of last night were from Iranian and international sources, blogs, and human rights groups.

Today, the mainstream media started to pick up on it, with stories from the Los Angeles Times, BBC, United Press International, New York Times, and a few others. Still, at the time of writing this post there are only 206 news stories about Delara Darabi’s unjust execution. By comparison, there are currently 762 news stories about Matthew McConaughey, and 7,078 news stories about Arlen Specter.

So, how, you might ask, did word of the story first break? Who reported it first? The answer is: Darabi’s execution was first reported on Twitter. And then the first media outlet to pick up the story was none other than the epitome of new media, BreakingTweets.com, a news site which reports stories from around the world using Twitter for breaking news. BreakingTweets isn’t run by seasoned news pros, either — its founder and head is Craig Kanalley, a twentysomething journalism grad student trying to revolutionize the way we get our news, through the use of new media.

Breaking Tweets was paying attention to the Delara Darabi story, and they reported it more than a full 24 hours before the mainstream media.

Delara Darabi’s story should be seen as a case study of some of the challenges with our media system as it stands today:

Ethnocentrism still reigns supreme: stories with an “American” angle - like the imprisonment of American journalist Roxana Saberi in Iran - are more important than similar stories, like Delara Darabi’s, without the American angle. With Roxana Saberi, international media attention has been fierce — and because of that, so has international pressure on Iranian authorities. Had Delara Darabi had that kind of attention, she could have had a very different fate. But she didn’t get that attention - because she’s not American.

And new media won major points. Old media types who rail against new media, such as NYT’s Maureen Dowd and Matt Bai, who spent last week complaining about Twitter, should take note: the New York Times was shamefully far, far behind Twitter and new media in picking up this story.

Where are our media’s priorities? What is driving them to choose to write 7000+ of the same stories on Arlen Specter, and almost nothing about the international law-violating execution of an innocent young Iranian woman?

Perhaps it is because human rights stories just don’t sell as much as stories about high-intensity partisan clashes or Hollywood actors. Human rights stories, particuarly world news, may sell less copies or bring in few page views. But news isn’t supposed to be about the profit motive — it’s supposed to be about educating and informing the masses about the world around them. If the press is to act as an arbiter of what is news, they should be reporting on what matters, rather than more banal stories about the White House puppy or Michelle Obama’s garden.

Share and Enjoy:

Comments

05.04.09

The value of human life has never been equal in mainstream media. Australian media will report endlessly about events that involve deaths of US or UK citizens but will ignore completely events that involve similar or far worse goings on in non-"white" (or even non english-speaking) parts of the world. Chicken or egg? Media's fault or reflection of society's fickle nature? Or is it more because those crazy Africans are always killing each other anyway so it's never news worthy? Who knows.

V
05.04.09

I honestly couldn't agree with you more. This is always a complaint of mine and its shameful of the American media to ignore such pressing issues and keeping the majority of Americans ignorant to what goes on around the world.

cooper.olivia
05.04.09

In this country, unless the stories are about a middle class Caucasian, especially a female, it won't be covered. It won't be covered because no one watches the coverage. The media is consumer driven.

I'd like to say they should have covered it, yet they don't even cover, to any degree, cases just a upsetting here.

There is also some consideration to be given to the fact that she originally admitted to the crime but recanted once she obtained a lawyer, and as we (US) only stopped executing juveniles in 2004 it does not make a story where we can point to Iran as the biggest and the scariest, and if it's not the biggest and scariest then it's not a story that will sell.

The choice is not to watch the ridiculous stuff, I don't nor probably do you but that leaves the rest of the country and honestly I don't think they really care. New media helps with that and it will be more so in the future.

05.04.09

I am generally on the fence on the issue of whether to bail out the newspapers or not, but when I hear about fuckups like this, I can't help but cheer on the demise of these gray ladies.

The New York Times has pretended to be an honest player with progressive leanings, but they've always been about placating the status quo.

LET THEM FAIL!

Nisha Chittal
05.04.09

@Alex - very good point. No one really knows whether media doesn't care, or the media doesn't report because society doesn't care.

@Passionista - yeah, it does leave Americans more ignorant to what goes on in the rest of the world and also puts the responsibility on people to seek out different news sources; but few people have the time or will to do that

@Olivia - that's a good point, but the complete lack of coverage is still almost startling. And she recanted because she said she was persuaded to take the blame - there's definitely some details there that are still unclear.

@Tim - I don't know that I want mainstream media to FAIL, but I do agree that sometimes big media is just maintaining the status quo rather than contributing new and original stories from around the world.

Iranian boy
05.05.09

I do agree and I think that unfortunately the media ignored Delara's case. Regrettably, nowadays there is no equal and fair attitude toward human rights issues. While you can hear lots of news about "Roxana Saberi" another woman imprisoned in Iran, this parallel case of "Delara" poorly cosidered. And the eventual outcome of this unfairness was Delara's shocking execution. In fact, the Iranian regime chose "Delara" as a victim because it was feeling less international pressure compared with Roxana's case.
But what is the reason of this unfairness? As you may know "Roxana Saberi" has another nationality (American) other than her Iranian nationalty. Thus, the attentions towards her and consequently news in media about her are much prominent. But "Delara" was a poor Iranian girl from "Rasht" which I believe many don't ever know even where it is. So "who cares about her case?!". But I hope to see a day when everybody all aroud the world feel freedom and humanity equally!

Got Something To Say?

Got Something To Say?

You Must Be Logged In To Comment
Not a Member? Brazen Careerist is a career management tool for next-generation professionals. Set up a free account today to comment on this post and start sharing your ideas. Learn more.

Network Roulette

Schedule an Event
kyna Snapshot .jpg
mobilephonecheapdeals.org_.uk_.png
drapeau_france.jpg

Ask A Citi Recruiter Zone

Q: I'm trying to change careers by leveraging my skills ... (More...)
A: Hi Dean: Tramyra just posted a similar question, and you ... (More...)

Jobs

  • Page 1 of 3
Content Affiliations Associate - 162806
Newark - Amazon
Content Creation Supervisor - 162810
Newark - Amazon
Assistant Audio Mastering Engineer - 162816
Newark - Amazon
Financial Analyst - 162922
Jersey City - Amazon
Account Manager - DEFL117247
Wall Township - Safeway Inc

Employer? Post a job