Already a member?

Click here to login

Welcome to Brazen Careerist!

Matt Elliott is using Brazen Careerist to share ideas. Join now to become a member and start networking with Matt Elliott and other professionals just like you. Learn more.

Posted On 02.25.09

There’s a recession all over the world. Which is nice, because I like it when we all have something in common. I’ve written about the recession few times. I’ll write about it some more. Much like the Jonas Brothers or skinny jeans, it won’t last forever, but it’s definitely not going away for a while. So we’ve got to learn to cope.

Like any recession, there’s a lot of hype these days. Newspapers, maybe because they’re shedding jobs faster than everyone else, are banging a ceaseless drum about this presumed fiscal apocalypse. And yes, it sucks, and yes, it will suck for at least another couple of years, but it’s important for members of Generation Y not to take all this doom-and-gloom rhetoric and make bad choices in the short-term that could seriously screw with their long-term career goals.

It’s critical that us young people, in the face of the specter of soup lines and cardboard houses, to not give in to hype-driven impulsiveness and make mistakes. Don’t panic.

No one’s in greater danger of this than those who are looking at graduating college or university this spring. When I graduated in 2006, I was looking forward to it — there was something exciting about stepping out into the world. Now, it’s a little bit like walking The Green Mile.

Take this article from the Kansas City Star: The perils of graduating college in 2009:

With so many experienced people out of work, how is a new grad supposed to compete? Many companies prefer to hire someone who is tested and knowledgeable in their industry rather than taking a flyer on a new kid. And those laid off folks are desperate too, often willing to take significantly lower salaries to land a gig.

Columnist Michael Stahl is right, of course, in that you’d have to either be a supergenius or an incredible moron to expect lucrative employment right out of college these days. But, again, I have to emphasize how important the ‘not panicking’ part of this is. I’m hearing about a lot of grads who are making really dumb decisions in light of the economy.

Here are three big career mistakes you should avoid right now, no matter how safe and secure - and even sensible - they might sound:

1. Don’t go to grad school

Look, I’ve got nothing against graduate school in theory. And, by all means, if you’re the kind of person who legitimately loves learning and being in academia — if you could see yourself spending your life tangled up in it — than grad school could absolutely be the right path for you.

But don’t do grad school because you have some misguided notion that it’s going to magically help your employment prospects. Penelope Trunk already covered this pretty well::

Applications to the military increase in a bad economy in a disturbingly similar way that applications to graduate school do. For the most part, both alternatives are bad. They limit your future in ways you can’t even imagine, and they are not likely to open the kind of doors you really want. Military is the terrible escape hatch for poor kids, and grad school is the terrible escape hatch for rich kids.

Even short grad school programs (One or two years) tend to offer little more than lipstick on a pig. If you don’t have the drive toward academia - and especially if you’re considering paying for grad school through student loans that will bury you into your forties — all you’re doing is avoiding reality.

2. Don’t become a teacher

One of my big anger-triggers these days is the seemingly widespread belief that teaching is a universally-palatable career choice that pretty much ANYONE with a BA can get into, be good at, and secure sustained employment. It’s not, it shouldn’t be, and trying to push the teaching profession down that road will undoubtedly screw with the education of young people for years to come.

Ignoring the fact that teaching is an incredible important occupation that should be the domain of our best and brightest, teaching isn’t even really all that stable these days. It made all sorts of sense when birth rates were high all over, but demographics are changing. Teachers are facing layoffs all over because there are a glut of teachers and not that many students.

I have a BA in History. I know that a lot of BAs get fed crap about how teaching (or grad/law school) is the only career option out there for them. But that’s not true. Just because your pathway isn’t lit up for you with guide lights doesn’t mean it’s not there.

3. Don’t base everything on statistics

There is, and there has always been, a lot of merit to looking at statistics before launching yourself toward a certain career. Researching your employment sector, looking at employment trends and average salaries — these are smart things to do.

But the danger here is in putting too much weight on the stats. The stats will say, for example, that you’re far better off going into structural engineering than, say, journalism. Many orders of magnitude better off. The difference between those two career paths is literally hundreds of thousands of dollars.

But if you have no desire to be a structural engineer — and your whole life you’ve wanted to be in journalism — none of that will matter. Life is always easier when you have a ton of money in the bank and you’re not living off Ramen noodles, but it’s not necessarily always better.

Giving up on your passions is absolutely the biggest mistake you can make in this economic climate. Not only because it’ll probably make you miserable, but also because that which you’re passionate about tends to be what you’re good at. It sounds a bit cliché and kind of like something the Care Bears would chant, but I believe it: your talent follows your passion.

Accentuating the Negative

I know, I know — I’ve only told you what NOT to do, and not given you any kind of advice on what TO do. But that’s kind of the point. The current job market demands patience. The only proactive advice I can really give at this point is to be vigilant. And to get a job — any job you can — that will provide you experience and the money you need to get by.

The best thing you can do for yourself right now is NOT screw up. You don’t have kids, a mortgage, imminent retirement plans or other major liabilities. You’ve got patience that others won’t have. And time will reward Generation Y for that.

Share and Enjoy:

Comments

Editor's Note: Inappropriate comments that are offensive to the author or not in context to the author's post will be removed. For editorial feedback, please contact our Community Manager through his user profile. Click here.
Ann
February 25, 2009 11:17 am

Great advice, Matt, especially with points 1 & 2. However, I disagree on point #2. Here in Ohio, there is a great need for elementary teachers, math and science and technology teachers, and principals. Special needs positions are now overfilled. Social studies very much also. Keep the faith.

Ann
February 25, 2009 11:19 am

Sorry, read before submitting. Wasn't that yesterday's advice? I meant to say -- absolutely, I'm in agreement with points 1 & 3. Point #3 is most important in finding your job and ultimate career. Without passion, life lacks energy.

February 25, 2009 12:14 pm

"No one’s in greater danger of this than those who are looking at graduating college or university this spring. "

I think that recently laid off 50-60 year olds are definitely in worse danger than new grads. All that experience can work against you as you get older: companies may pass over more experienced workers because they are more expensive.

That said, I do think your advice to Millennials is sound. But it also reveals a unique bias in the Millennial generation: the desire not to screw it up. As a Generation X'er I often give advice to younger friends to take risks and be willing to make mistakes. But when it comes to career paths it seems like that advice now falls on deaf ears. I understand the reasons for this and have decided to change my approach. Although taking risks and learning in the school of hard knocks was a hallmark of my generation, it does not apply as well to Millennials.

Thanks for your post. I may write something about this Gen X/Millennial shift in attitude regarding the career path on my blog at http://www.thegenxfiles.com sometime soon.

February 25, 2009 12:34 pm

I'm hard-pressed to think about how taking a less-than-ideal job as a new grad can ruin your life forever. A job is a big part of daily life, and no one wants a bad one, or to get stuck in a career path that isn't fulfilling. But it takes a while to do that.

People have been changing careers for decades. That means there's no need to panic about taking "the wrong job" either.

February 25, 2009 12:38 pm

A, I can't believe there is an article titled "the perils of graduating in 2009." Eff that. I don't think such a pessimistic outlook is going to do anything except get college seniors more worried and stressed than they already are. I refused to be that gloomy.

That aside, I like your post - some great points. Going to grad school is something I've seen a lot more of my friends latch on to as a safety net to ride out the recession. And you're definitely right about teaching -- lots of people are going into it as a "safe" occupation but that will ruin the quality of the education we're giving to America's kids, and shouldn't be encouraged. Well said.

February 25, 2009 12:39 pm

I think you're making some overgeneralizations here. No doubt, graduate degrees are necessary for some fields. If you want to work with international organizations like the UN or US AID, you definitely need a graduate degree! You'll need a graduate degree to get into policy of any sort, and I can think of many more situations where it is helpful (other than being a lawyer, etc). Also, there is a difference between being a teacher and being a professor. What do you say about being a college professor? I still see that as one of the most stable positions out there, provided you can get tenure.

February 25, 2009 1:04 pm

"What do you say about being a college professor? I still see that as one of the most stable positions out there, provided you can get tenure."

@Akhila, I say that's a big "if." In many fields, there aren't that many positions. As more experienced professors retire, many institutions are (a) not hiring, or (b) hiring people as lecturers and adjuncts rather than for tenure-track positions.

No one should get a Ph.D. with the idea that it is likely to get them a job. As with any other career, they should look carefully at hiring trends and their real prospects as applicants.

On the other hand, I think that if someone wants a Ph.D. just because they want it, why not go for it? That outcome is much more certain.

The Office Newb
February 25, 2009 1:50 pm

One of my pet peeves is the recruitment of nurses. Yes, there's a shortage. Yes, nurses can make great money with relatively minimal training.

However, what makes people think that just anyone off the street can become a nurse?

I mean, you actually have to know stuff and take care of people. It's not like you can just put a syringe in someone's hand and let them go to it. Sheesh.

Let's all give nurses and teachers more credit than that.

February 25, 2009 9:33 pm

I thoroughly agree with everything said in this post (especially point #1 & 3). I honestly feel that people use grad school as a means to get out of working. It is almost impossible to land your “dream job” right out of college. In fact, it is all the crappy jobs that will enable you to appreciate your “dream job” when it finally does arrive (or you can go the entrepreneur route like I did—I got sick of waiting).

Plus, I hate to say this, but these days it is who you know and not what you know (at least in my experience). I have seen many people go off to grad school get themselves further in debt and still not land a job, while those who do not know as much get promoted into positions they should not be in the first place.

Sure times are hard, but it’s not impossible to succeed—it just takes effort and determination.

Matt Elliott
February 25, 2009 9:42 pm

Good points, everyone. I do want to clarify that I've got nothing against grad school and teaching as a rule -- just some of the bizarre justifications people use in order to pursue them.

Especially with teaching, I think it's critical that more smart, creative people consider going that route. What I hate is when someone gets a BA, panics because they can't find anything but a McJob right out of school, and decides to become a teacher despite having no real interest or inclination toward educating young people.

Thanks for all the comments!

February 26, 2009 12:30 am

As a grad student I have to agree with your comment about not going to grad school as a 'back up plan.' Grad school is a huge commitment and if you are not passionate about your subject you won't enjoy it and you likely won't thrive. Grad school is hard work, and a huge time and financial commitment!

Nice post

Scott
February 26, 2009 7:41 am

First, your comment about the military is ignorant and disrespectful. Maybe you should have read all the shit Penelope took when she first stated it. Also, if you look at the socio-economic background of people who enlist in the military, they come from families who have a household income slightly above the national average. Those statistics don't even consider commissioned officers-who come from families with much higher household incomes.

Second, not all grad schools are created equal. I know many people graduating in two months with 6 figure jobs lined up. (hint - they are not getting masters in history, english, psych, etc)

Got Something To Say?

Got Something To Say?

You Must Be Logged In To Comment
Not a Member? Brazen Careerist is a career management tool for next-generation professionals. Set up a free account today to comment on this post and start sharing your ideas. Learn more.
UberOps Color Logo Only.png
missWorcesterExt.gif
TheThe.jpg
globe.jpg

Grad School Zone

ScottShrum.jpg
Scott Shrum

This is the time of year when, every time the phone rings here at Veritas Prep HQ, there's a good chance it's an applicant calling to ask us if he should apply to business school in the third admissions round, or if he should wait until next year. The answer, as is the answer for most things in life, is "It depends."

Personal Branding

me.JPG
Becky Leung

There has been a great deal written about how to engage with social media to establish a name for yourself online, but a commonly overlooked piece of the puzzle is also one of the simplest: owning your own domain name. A domain name complements the rest of your online presence through branding using yourname.com or a similar variation.

Abercrombie & Fitch Co....
Copywrite Manager
Java Developer
Procter & Gamble Co....
Manufacturing Engineer In...
Chemicals Internship...
Sony Pictures Entertainme...
Administrative Assistant ...
Business Analyst
Randstad
Branch Manager
Agent
X