Welcome to Brazen Careerist!
Emily Ma is using Brazen Careerist to share ideas. Join now to become a member and start networking with Emily Ma and other professionals just like you. Learn more.
Emily Ma is using Brazen Careerist to share ideas. Join now to become a member and start networking with Emily Ma and other professionals just like you. Learn more.
It was President's Day. I was off work and traipsing around on Twitter. Ok, I guess you can't really traipse there in a literal sense, but I was doing the virtual equivalent. MSNBC was on in the background. Luke Russert comes on. He's interviewing Bill Clinton. I look up.
Something about advice for young people in this economy? I don't really remember, but then as the anchor was closing out with Russert, something caught my ear. The anchor said something about how people can connect with Russert and mentioned Twitter. Russert then said something like, "I'm not on Twitter yet, still looking into that."
Still looking into that?! That's the sort of response I might expect to hear from a 60 year old. I hit the keyboard and in fewer than 140 characters I tweet some version of what I'm thinking:
Immediately I get some responses. A few DMs, some @replies. Some interesting tweeting ensues. Here's a selection:
------------------
henrim @jwschiff how is that absurd? The youth population on Twitter is not at all representative the rest of youth population.
jwschiff @henrim it's not about representation, but huge part of the Gen. Y story is technology, social media, seems silly not to monitor that part
KathleenLD @henrim agreed. The youth demographic on Twitter is not representative of youth as a whole. More tech/journ heavy than the general pop, even
jwschiff @KathleenLD @henrim don't you think it's a problem Russert doesn't have access to this convo? Twitter isn't everything, but imp. 2 follow
henrim @jwschiff @KathleenLD we are overachievers, hyper-connected, overely-political geeks... i say that in the nicest way possible.
jwschiff @henrim yes, but u don't think with the thousands of twittr articles there's a youth angle? and if not, that's worth reporting too
henrim @jwschiff @KathleenLD I would gladly give up the youth angle coverage on twitter if he covers college cost/debt in more dept.
Some other thoughts:
Nextvoice247 @jwschiff he cvers youth issues as an observer & not actve participant; "sees" youth, but finds himself n role of old guard w fresh face
nishachittal @jwschiff interesting about Luke Russert. But I think most journos still dont get Twitter. Just look at @andersoncooper or @gstephanopoulos
------------------
So henrim and KathleenLD have valid points. Yes, those of us on Twitter are part of a small group of the "youth" demographic or pretty much any other age group. But we're also part of an emerging trend, and that's a story.
But here's the gist of why I was shocked to hear that Russert isn't on Twitter:
As an NBC News correspondent-at-large (bio here), he is tasked with reporting on stories with a youth angle. NBC brought him aboard just as the presidential elections were heading into the home stretch and announced that Russert would cover the youth vote during the election cycle.
Social media is a huge part of some of these stories. Russert even talked about the importance of the Internet angle. Gen. Y and younger generations are notoriously plugged in and spend a lot of time interacting online. A journalist who is on a youth beat needs to be monitoring what happens online, this MediaShift post raises a lot of these issues and at the very least shows that Twitter is a part of the conversation.
Twitter certainly isn't the entire story, but it's like covering a school district and only attending official meetings. Good reporters would dig deeper. They interact with students, parents, teachers and administrators in a variety of settings. They pay attention to informal channels, off-the-cuff remarks and read between the lines.
In all fairness to Russert, he is blogging, kind of (no updates since October and very few links, posts look like articles). But seriously, I don't know what he's up against with bureaucracy and other barriers at NBC. Perhaps contracts and other things prevent him from being enterprising in this way, and he only graduated from college last May! He also freely admits that nepotism certainly plays a role in how he ended up in this gig -- in October, he told MediaBistro, "Did my name get my foot in the door? Absolutely, I'll be the first to admit that. But has my performance and ability got my butt through the door? Yes."
But with all that considered, I think Russert would have been better off if he were plugged in and paying attention.
Jaclyn,
You are spot on with this post. I checked into some of your links to see if Luke Russert was plugged into social media using tools other than Twitter but I couldn't find them if they exist. I did find a later blog entry for him at http://blogs.icue.com/ dated 12/04/08 which was strange since his blog is at http://blogs.icue.com/luke-russert/ as you say above.
Luke has a double major at BC of history and communications. His approach to media online appears to me as the conventional print model in digital format. I don't think he understands social media and that includes blogs. He didn't get down into the comments section of his last two posts and the comments in the last post are mostly porn (literally). In my opinion he needs to get some more hands on experience with social media in order to walk the walk.
Mark
@Mark W. thanks and I appreciate you doing the additional research!
I imagine his dad must have had a big influence on his approach to media and there is definitely a lot of value in some aspects of that traditional attitude. But with him being a youth correspondent, I think there's just a BIG opportunity here to carve out interesting, new approaches to broadcast media and help NBC attract younger viewers to newscasts in new ways. But I don't see him even getting his feet wet!
But again, he's new on the job and I'm sure it's a big learning curve. So maybe the best is yet to come?

You know what I just noticed, David Gregory is on Twitter. And his account seems legit, like he is an actual person twittering, not just a twitterfeed like anderson cooper or Stephanopoulos.
David Gregory! But not Luke Russert! Now Russert is just beginning to look more and more behind the times.

Now, wait a minute!
David Gregory was born in 1970, which makes him a GenX. He's younger than me (1969) and I'm on Twitter and interested in social media!
I really don't think this is an age thing.

@JLWagner -- you are right, I didn't mean to imply it was an age thing at all. If you check out Jaclyn's original post on her blog I had left another comment suggesting that I don't think social media is unique to young people at all, plenty of Gen X/boomers are interested in it as well.
The more I think about it the more I think it is not that Russert should be on Twitter because of his age and generational issues, but because if he is a journalist who is supposed to be on the cutting edge and who is supposed to be providing the people with information and insight, it's his responsibility to be monitoring the conversation going on in social media and to know what is going on. He is pretty out of touch, in my opinion, if he is not doing that -- and that is not an age thing at all.

That's why I love Rick Sanchez mid-days on CNN. He Twitters and shares viewer comments on-screen. Sometimes it's dumb, like "Nice glasses, Rick!" But it's really cool b/c it's interactive, gives "real people" perspectives and "real" opposing viewpoints. He uses Twitter to get story ideas too and I think he's really broken the mold. Twittering about his knee surgery may have gone a tad too far, however.

Well, I'm 46, and I'm on Twitter! And Luke got on Twitter after David Shuster from MSNBC brought him up to speed: http://twitter.com/russertXM_NBC
There are SCADS of journalists on Twitter, doing it well! A partial list:
http://twitter.com/oknox
http://twitter.com/mmadden
http://twitter.com/maddow - Rachel Maddow
http://twitter.com/willatwork - One of Rachel's producers
http://twitter.com/toryatwork - one of Keith Olbermann's producers
http://twitter.com/shuster1600 - David Shuster
http://twitter.com/thefix - The Washington Post's Chris Cillizza
http://twitter.com/terrymoran - Nightline co-anchor
http://twitter.com/mikeallen - Politico's Mike Allen
http://twitter.com/anamariecox - Former Wonkette, now Air America Whitehouse correspondent
http://twitter.com/tamronhall - MSNBC's Tamron Hall
http://twitter.com/contessabrewer - MSNBC's Contessa Brewer
More join in all the time: http://search.twitter.com/search?q=%23journotwits