Where ambitious young professionals connect and grow

Already a member?

Click here to login

Welcome to Brazen Careerist!

Emily Ma is using Brazen Careerist to share ideas. Join now to become a member and start networking with Emily Ma and other professionals just like you. Learn more.

  
Posted On 01.15.09

Good bosses by typical, static definitions don’t exist. Young professionals tend to link Good Boss criteria with traits that have nothing to do with being an effective manager.

Therefore, a disconnect appears between the invented definition and the reality of what makes a Good Boss. Such invented criteria can be be difficult to solidify.

Someone who knows how to communicate with me

That’s a tall order. Whether you believe it

Share and Enjoy:

Comments

01.15.09

I'm fortunate that I have a fantastic relationship with my boss, due to a previous internship I did with him almost 10 years prior to taking the position that I'm in. I've found that if communication is a two-way street (including some issues that could be considered personal), then many of the points you mention just seem to fall in line.

01.15.09

Great post.
I don't believe that there is such a thing as a perfect boss, because one size never fits all. A good/perfect boss for me might be your nightmare dictator.
What I do know, from personal experience, is that there are some very incompetent managers and bosses that really know how to make employees' lives miserable.
Bosses that give vague instructions, are over-confident, react over-emotionally in business situations and don't know what it means when a conversation is supposed to be confidential.

There are good and bosses out there what you will never find is a perfect boss. Which is what I think you mean in this article.

01.15.09

@Norcross
That's great you and your boss have a good relationship. I believe any (good) employee/boss relationship takes time and a willingness for both parties to *work* at syncing their communication well.

@Dawn van Emden
Thanks, I'm glad you enjoyed what I had to say. Good points about the incompetent managers. It gives me some stuff to think about for my upcoming post on ineffective managers.

jvaron7
01.15.09

The best bosses know each person's skill set and delegates based on that. They give projects that they know someone can do and then give projects that are challenging.

It's more of a give and take, rather than an all take or all give.

This is not good boss criteria - this is (good) job criteria. You’ll be surprised at how many interesting, challenging projects float over people’s heads because they simply didn’t ask for them. It’s not your boss’s job to keep you professionally stimulated or motivated.

I agree and disagree with this at the same time. A good boss, as I said before, delegates based on skill. Yes, it is an employee's job to ask for more stimulating projects, but it is also a boss's job to manage effectively. I had a boss once who was a great person, but was never able to find work for me to do. However, I knew there were interesting jobs for me; he just couldn't delegate them to me for whatever reason.

So, while I do agree that employees should take initiative about the projects they receive, a boss should also be able to empower and motivate their team.

01.15.09

@Jamie Varon
Being able to empower and motivate people are great boss traits to have, however, I believe that someone else's enthusiasm/willingness to motivate you can only go so far. Being able to keep your own soul focused, motivated, interested and enthusiatic for the work you do is primarily the worker's responsiblity (in my opinion). It's a choice we make everyday - are we going to challenge ourselves to be inspired? Or, are we going to rely on the crap shoot of being motivated by someone else?
In one way, it's a matter of what you would prefer: inspiring work/uninspiring boss or uninspiring work/inspired boss? The best would be a combination of both, but I personally think that if you are inspired to do your work anyway, an inspiring boss is a lucky bonus.
Great point - it's got me thinking about some other topics I could write in the future.

jvaron7
01.15.09

@Raven Moore

I definitely agree with you about not relying on other people's enthusiasm to motivate you. I am hoping that my comment did not come across that way.

Ideally, there would be a combination of the inspiring/uninspiring boss/work.

Being able to keep your own soul focused, motivated, interested and enthusiastic for the work you do is primarily the worker's responsibility (in my opinion).

However, don't you feel like it is a boss's responsibility to contribute to upholding that motivation? You have me thinking about my previous comment and maybe I have been putting too many expectations on a boss. Hmm.

The Office Newb
01.15.09

I agree with Jamie on her point. Even if you show initiative, a bad boss will likely be bent on keeping you down for whatever reason.

For example, my boss was always saying to let her know if there were projects we wanted to take on. When they announced my company was going to start blogging, I volunteered right away to do one for our business related site (I am The Office Newb, afterall). However, a few days later my boss came to me and said she had assigned a freelancer to do that and instead offered me the opportunity to write a culinary blog--something I'm neither qualified nor interested in. Ultimately I ended up not taking on the project.

I think that workers should absolutely be motivated and pro-active about seeking projects that interest them, however, when you are low on the totem pole, you just have to accept that sometimes people don't want to give you extra responsibility.

01.15.09

@Jamie Varon
Too many expectations? Hmmm. Maybe you are placing too many...and maybe you aren't.

As for responsiblity for providing motivation, to a degree, a boss *should* uphold motivation in a department - after all, it's in the boss's best interests to make sure that their workers are professionally stimulated and motivated.

But, in the case of a "good" boss definition, my previous point of a boss providing access to challenging work/encouraging professional development rounds it out. In other words, I think if a boss is providing those things for you - s/he is providing that motivation/enthusiasm you mention.

But in the end, no amount of enthusiasm/motivations from a boss is going to make up for an uninspired, de-motivated employee

01.15.09

@Office Newb
Your point is interesting. Extra responsiblity doesn't always mean "more interesting." It must means more work, which is not always what employees are looking for. But workplace antics like cronyism, favoritism aside, I'm sure effective managers have their reasons for not doling out what employees deem extra (or more interesting) responsibility.

Whether they're low on the totem pole or not...

The blogging project you describe sounds like something your boss thought you would like to do no matter what the topic. And, perhaps, it didn't cross her mind that you volunteered for it b/c of the blogging/subject appeal.

So, when she decided to have a freelancer write the business blog and approached you about the culinary blog, it obviously didn't occur to her that is why you signed up to do the project in the first place (to write the business blog).

I could be wrong - you know better than I do about that.

Did you ever have a conversation about why she opted to work with a freelancer and not you?

jvaron7
01.15.09

@The Office Newb - That is a great example of a boss just not knowing the best way to utilize their employees. No amount of motivation can conquer a boss like that, unless one wants to seriously ruffle some feathers.

@Raven Moore - No amount of anything can make up for an uninspired, de-motivated person. They wouldn't know a great project if it was right under them! =)

Raven
01.15.09

@Jamie Varon
You're right. A de-motivated, uninspired person would be just as miserable with a *good* boss as they would be with a bad boss. So, it doesn't matter if the boss is inspiring if the employee can't find their own motivation to remain (or become) inspired.

Raven
01.15.09

@Jamie Varon
Let me just add that I agree with your point that an uninspired employee probably wouldn't recognize challenging work - wouldn't that go with my argument that if they aren't motivated from within there isn't much a motivating boss can do?

jvaron7
01.15.09

@ Raven Moore - Absolutely. I'm not arguing that a motivating boss can motivate anyone. I'm saying that a motivating boss will be the best at upholding and sustaining an already motivated employee. And, potentially, motivate someone who may have lost inspiration at a job.

There always needs to be a base of enthusiasm to begin with. I think we both agree on that. What I think we differ on is how much emphasis must be placed on the boss to inspire and motivate their employees to action versus what happens when a motivated person encounters a boss who is uninspiring. It has been my experience that the unmotivated, poorly performing boss could eventually unmotivate their team, no matter how intrinsically inspired they are.

Then again, maybe I haven't been around people who are so motivated that it wouldn't matter if their boss was Michael Scott from The Office, they'd still be superstars!

Mary
07.23.09

I think that my boss is a very good one. He's not the typical boss but he always makes sure the job gets done. He yells and threatens to punish but we know that it is all deserved and he has good intentions. He gives us a bit of freeway and makes it clear when our deadlines are, which are always reasonable. He's also very understandable and gets himself involved in projects and tasks that a boss wouldn't usually do.

Got Something To Say?

Got Something To Say?

You Must Be Logged In To Comment
Not a Member? Brazen Careerist is a career management tool for next-generation professionals. Set up a free account today to comment on this post and start sharing your ideas. Learn more.

Network Roulette

Schedule an Event
longbeachgarage.jpg
4.jpeg
Wayfair Coupon.jpg

Ask A Citi Recruiter Zone

Q: I'm trying to change careers by leveraging my skills ... (More...)
A: Hi Dean: Tramyra just posted a similar question, and you ... (More...)

Jobs

  • Page 1 of 3
Content Affiliations Associate - 162806
Newark - Amazon
Content Creation Supervisor - 162810
Newark - Amazon
Assistant Audio Mastering Engineer - 162816
Newark - Amazon
Financial Analyst - 162922
Jersey City - Amazon
Account Manager - DEFL117247
Wall Township - Safeway Inc

Employer? Post a job