Where ambitious young professionals connect and grow

Already a member?

Click here to login

Welcome to Brazen Careerist!

Emily Ma is using Brazen Careerist to share ideas. Join now to become a member and start networking with Emily Ma and other professionals just like you. Learn more.

  
Posted On 09.05.08

I don’t belong here. They might as well ask me to leave, that’s how obvious it is that I’m an outsider in this arrangement. They must know. I’m not a scholar. I’m not a big-picture thinker. I’m not filling the role that this place at the table requires.

These were just some of the ridiculously insecure thoughts that were running through my head as I sat silently through a three-hour seminar tonight. I tracked the discussion as everyone around the room had something to contribute, until it was only me and the girl sitting next to me who hadn’t spoke. When having something to say is a percentage of your grade, and you are graded on the quality of what you actually articulate, staying in that silent minority is not an option.

Grad school has shown me that leading a group discussion is one of my major weaknesses. The two times I’ve had to do it in previous classes, I have totally bombed. My failure was so complete that I thought my best course of action would be to admit failure and ask the professor for feedback on how I could improve. It helped redeem my participation score somewhat, but the feedback didn’t actually improve my conversation facilitation skills.

But on the other hand, classes have also shown me that saying something, anything, in a room full of highly intellectual people carries the potential to make a point. So, even though I couldn’t quote the rhetoricians of the 19th and 20th centuries, I was able to understand enough to blurt out a coherent statement and thus somewhat contribute to the discussion.

Class isn’t the only place I’m running into insecurity, though. It’s the most obvious, because it’s the most different from what had become my day-to-day routine. But at work, I’m dealing with insecure coworkers. It’s been interesting to observe how insecurity manifests itself. For me, I tend to be incredibly quiet, building up courage to blurt out that one desperate statement. At work, it’s being asked “Did I do okay?” or on the other hand being told by a coworker “I did a really good job on this project,” only to have to affirm that statement because it’s just so damn awkward. Or, I’m being asked by another coworker “Are you mad at me?” in a lovable way, but still so frequently that I have to wonder if I come off as a raging bitch sometimes.

What do you think of insecure people? Having worked with a few in my short career, my reaction tends to be sympathy first, followed by confusion (seriously, this person has no business being insecure), followed by annoyance at the extreme high-maintenance of the situation. But, as I start to experience these feelings of insecurity myself, I’m super conscious of how I come across to other people because I’ve hit the annoyance stage with my coworkers.

So, I set limits. For instance, before class I was ok confessing that most of the reading was completely over my head. And my classmates reassured me that the only reason they understood it was because they had taken a similar class before and it had all be over their heads during that first class, too. But, I WON’T whine, “You know, I just didn’t get it” when it comes my turn to speak, and I won’t ask everyone else to affirm that “This stuff is really hard, right?”

The bottom line, I guess, is that it’s ok to be a little insecure when starting new things or reaching new chapters of your life. On the other hand, if you are chronically insecure, maybe it’s time to look at what you’re doing and decide if you really should be in a role that you suspect you may fail or suck at. If you don’t have the confidence that you’ll do the job, the nice coworkers will try to build you up and share their confidence that you can — honest ones or ones who have hit their reassurance quota will have no choice but to watch you tear yourself down with doubt.

Share and Enjoy:

Comments

Karen
09.05.08

The girl sitting next to you who hadn't spoken either? I'm that girl!In grad school, I had to force myself to speak up in discussions, even if I didn't really think I had anything important to say.

I once attended a "hiring class"- a group interview situation. After arriving and beginning discussion, I realized that I had somehow accidentally read the wrong section of the article that we were given to prepare. Everyone spoke up and talked about what they had found interesting in the article, until I was only one of two people in the room who hadn't spoken. I knew that wouldn't get me hired.

I waited until my first opportunity to say ANYTHING that was somewhat intelligent that wouldn't reveal my lack of preparation. I continued to speak up at every opportunity until I was no longer the quietest person in the discussion.

I got the job, and part of my feedback was that at first they weren't going to hire me because I was too quiet. And that other person who talked less than me didn't get hired.

It's the same in grad school- you just can't get an A if you're quiet (at least in some fields). Keep practicing- it gets easier!

Tiffany
09.07.08

I heard Bobby Flay (the chef) say something so obvious, but inspiring on The Big Idea once. Donny Deutsch asked him what has made him so successful, and Flay said that all he did was constantly think to himself, "Why not me?"
I find myself thinking "Who the hell am I?" all the time, just like you were in the seminar. You have to remember that other people are not nearly as smart or experienced as they seem, and that you are way more capable than most, not matter what your experience. Just keep telling yourself, "Why not me?" (And keep it rhetorical).

I know this may sound crazy, but try taking a beginners improv class geared toward regular people, not actors. Sometimes you just have to rip off the band-aid every time, until it's not so scary anymore.

Jessica Bond
09.08.08

It is never over until you decide its over. Never, ever give up on something that you really want. In the work place, it is rare to find people who want to see a peer out-perform them - that is why peer pressure is so strong. Want to raise your standards - hang out with people who are outperforming you.

Louisa
09.09.08

Being a bit insecure when you start a job is only natural. The first day of a job can be awkward, but it shouldn't prevent you from performing well or missing out on an opportunity. There is definitely a line though and if someone is having problems with their insecurity then they should probably seek help. Currently, I work at a staffing company, Hollister Staffing (www.hollisterstaff.com) and make sure to spend time with my clients after I have placed them to help transition into their new jobs and to feel comfortable in a new setting. Being nervous is normal, and the insecurity will pass in no time!

Got Something To Say?

Got Something To Say?

You Must Be Logged In To Comment
Not a Member? Brazen Careerist is a career management tool for next-generation professionals. Set up a free account today to comment on this post and start sharing your ideas. Learn more.

Network Roulette

Schedule an Event
idaho_map.jpg
prowrite_logo copy.jpg
asap LOgo.jpg

Ask A Citi Recruiter Zone

Q: I'm trying to change careers by leveraging my skills ... (More...)
A: Hi Dean: Tramyra just posted a similar question, and you ... (More...)

Jobs

  • Page 1 of 3
Content Affiliations Associate - 162806
Newark - Amazon
Content Creation Supervisor - 162810
Newark - Amazon
Assistant Audio Mastering Engineer - 162816
Newark - Amazon
Financial Analyst - 162922
Jersey City - Amazon
Account Manager - DEFL117247
Wall Township - Safeway Inc

Employer? Post a job