Why No One Should Bother to Blog Anonymously

Lance has a great piece here about the struggle that some HR pro's go through to blog without revealing who they really are, as in, their name. But his point applies to everyone who's blogging and is tempted to use examples from their work life, or even friends from just their personal life.
---your Brazen editor

As you may have heard, HR Wench is out of the anonymous closet. She’s a fellow Portlander so I’ve been encouraging her to reveal herself but for slightly selfish reasons. But for every anonymous HR person revealing their true identity, there are probably three more starting blogs under the shroud of secrecy. Why does this happen?

I guess it is more of a rhetorical question. I know why HR people start blogs anonymously. I was one of those people so I understand the thinking behind it. It is very simple from where I was:

  1. I am a bit paranoid. I don’t want my bosses or my employees to read about this but my wife is tired of hearing me talk about HR stuff. I’ll do it anonymously.
  2. Writing anonymously gives me more freedom to write as I please including making fun of co-workers or even my boss. Woohoo!
  3. I am a representative for my company so I speak for them. My blog will be boring if I have to limit myself to stuff the company approves.
  4. If I blog openly, it could open all kinds of legal traps. Perhaps I say I am against so and so act and then an issue comes up at work and they find my blog. So much for any good faith effort claim!

And so on. There are probably a million different little reasons to blog anonymously as an HR pro. To me, there is one good reason to blog openly with your name:

Your message is about you (not your company) and if the message is about you, then the only way you can be authentic is to blog under your name.

To me, authenticity was important. It was putting my name behind my words and that was important enough for me to take the leap. Not to say that putting your name on your blog gives you instant authenticity (it doesn’t) but it does give you that potential.  And there are some terrific anonymous HR bloggers out there but people will always wonder who is that person behind the web page?

Some people may also dispute that a blog is about you. They are wrong. You may not be the topic but the blog is about what you think about those topics, how you react to different topics, how you interact with commenters, etc… The blog is YOU. Topic may vary.

But for HR people, it is a difficult decision and I struggled with it as well. I think it hinged on the fact that my employees/boss would be trying to read into it or that outsiders would try to read into what my company was doing. HR is not PR though and we (should be) as active as any other department in making sure that company is going in the right direction and be able to have open conversations. I put three rules in my head that made blogging as an open HR person easy:

  1. Nobody at work would be surprised at my blog entries. This required me to be open with my superiors and employees about what I was thinking. It brought a new level of accountability to the table. So when we discuss an issue at a meeting and they see that I blog about a similar issue, they don’t see something contradictory.
  2. Nobody comes to my blog for breaking news. At least about layoffs or other HR related things. While you might find me talking about a product or something cool we are doing, working on staffing plans is part of my job and people should be channeling official sources for that sort of information. I don’t do spin well so I won’t try on my blog.
  3. Don’t use negative examples from work. This is obviously political but I think it is necessary. Nobody should be the “Bob” in a bad supervisor example. If they can identify themselves from your example, you shouldn’t use it. Most of the bad stories in my blog come from other people who e-mail me or talk to me about their work.

I am all for HR bloggers making themselves known and I am happy to talk about my experience in even greater detail of going from anonymous to open.

Share and Enjoy:
Editor's Note: Inappropriate comments that are offensive to the author or not in context to the author's post will be removed. For editorial feedback, please contact our Community Manager through his user profile. Click here.
Ryan Paugh

Lance,

Great post. It's a topic that comes up a lot for me as a community developer.

HR is interesting because it's a career field that spans practically every market out there. So while it might be appropriate to blog openly in one type of business, it may not be appropriate in another.

Does that make sense? Do you run into HR professionals like yourself who want to blog openly, but can't because their company would freak?

August 4, 2008 3:48 pm
Lance

Hey Ryan,

I guess I personally have a difficult time figuring out who can't blog in HR? I know VP's of HR that openly blog so I know it can be done at all levels. I think it goes back to some of the issues HR people face which include:

1. Traditionalism - Where doing things the same way as yesterday is looked as preferable.
2. Paranoia - HR people may be more prone to look over their shoulders than other groups.

Obviously HR is a diverse group but I do think think they are affected by these issues more than other groups in the corporate world. Which is too bad because I think one of the things that holds HR back is this line of thinking where they feel more comfortable blogging in the shadows.

August 4, 2008 5:04 pm
John Carraway

I have to say that I disagree. I have an anonymous blog and it’s for a good reason: the information I share is truthful and can go against corporate policy and marketing. If what you’re sharing is so sanitized that you don’t need to be anonymous, why would I bother reading it? I could just ask someone in HR or another coworker at my actual place of employment. I try and deliver information that would benefit my readers, not necessarily the corporations themselves. I write about working in Corporate America and try and deliver a message that is truthful. The truth often goes against HR policies. If you really want to know how Fortune 500s work, I would advise a blog like mine. If you just want generic information from someone who works in HR, then read one of the other 100s of blogs out there. I think you make some great points and I enjoyed reading your article, but like most of the other generic articles out there, I didn’t really find any useful information that would help me succeed in my own career. I’m not interested in reading about the musing of some HR rep. for some generic company (I can get that anywhere). I’m interested in insider tips that will help me understand and navigate my workplace environment.

August 4, 2008 5:16 pm
Lance

John,

So are you saying that if you don't run an anonymous blog, you can't tell the truth? Or that your site won't be interesting?

That seems preposterous and is easily disproved. Look at the most utilized blogs on the internet. Very few of them are run by anonymous individuals. There is a reason for that.

You don't have a single subject on your site that I wouldn't happily tackle myself (in fact, I have often tackled them in 2+ years of blogging). You can make the value judgment yourself of course but I am comfortable with the level of readership I have coupled with the e-mails and comments I get.

The only difference between you and I is that you sit at your desk and stew about these things and then blog about them anonymously. I talk to my supervisor about it and express my opinions openly and then I blog about it. It is fine if you don't want to do that (it is difficult) but it seems silly to bag on my blog based on some perceived lost value.

Lance

August 4, 2008 9:48 pm

GOT SOMETHING TO SAY?

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <b> <i> <blockquote> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <p>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Subscribe to Brazen Careerist

q