Already a member?

Click here to login

Welcome to Brazen Careerist!

Presh Talwalkar is using Brazen Careerist to share ideas. Join now to become a member and start networking with Presh Talwalkar and other professionals just like you. Learn more.

Should you save more or earn more?

This is a frequent money question. It’s also a misguided one.

When I hear this question, I say I want both. I need to earn more so that I can enjoy higher quality products. But for a given income level, I need to save more so that I get more bang for my buck.

Posted On 03.20.08

Comments

Editor's Note: Inappropriate comments that are offensive to the author or not in context to the author's post will be removed. For editorial feedback, please contact our Community Manager through his user profile. Click here.
Todd Schultz
March 21, 2008 7:08 pm

I think the tax issue is a compelling one, however, it can never hurt to put in more hours at work. Also, figuring out a budget that works for you (and learning how to stick to it) is always recommended. Even if your making a million dollars a year.

Steve
March 23, 2008 12:25 am

"You'll be more likely to see me lazing on my sofa than spending more hours in the office."

How valuable is "lazing on my sofa time"?

I don't think our Chinese economic rivals share that attitude.

This is what I fear most about the future....

Presh Talwalkar
March 23, 2008 2:40 am

@Todd Shultz: Yes, earning more is certainly important. I see earning as more important to long-run stability and saving as more to short-run, but perhaps that's generalizing too much. I also agree that even millionaires have to plan out their spending.

@Steve: You raise a very good point. It is important for workers to be highly motivated for the economy. But people ultimately respond to incentives--many of my friends are getting burnt out by an American system of labor that highly favors owners instead of workers.

My labor economics professor stressed time and again that America is a weird country. It's one of the only places where rich people increase their hours of work relative to leisure. I'm not sure that can go on indefinitely.

And please don't take my comment literally :) I was writing for effect and image. I, and my readers, are very hard workers and top-notch "A" students. But I suspect we'd rather get an "A-" for half the effort of working for an "A+." Maybe that scares you too about the future, but I am fine with that.

Steve
March 23, 2008 5:22 pm

Our work ethic is what sets us apart from the rest of the world.

Advocating for a culture of A- work for less effort versus A+ work with greater effort means one thing to me - slacker.

When you have kids and a mortgage and responsibility, you'll come around during the growing up process.

And in a tight economy, A+ workers will be more valued than A- workers.

Being and remaining employed is about the best incentive out there. Without money, you have very little if any freedom.

Presh Talwalkar
March 23, 2008 7:43 pm

I see your point. The way you put it, I will have to grow up more to really judge the truth. Time will tell.

I can't answer you directly, but I will offer one more thought to the mix.

I don't agree A- workers are slackers. I advocate hard work, but I call for more efficient consumption, which is the use of the work (that's the "A-" part).

I think America as a society works hard but wastefully. In fact, I suggest that working more and more is leading us to wasteful activities. That work ethic is not improving our lives.

I know this first hand. When I worked late nights and weekends, I took a cab instead of a bus. I had food delivered by cars instead of strolling to nearby shops or cooking myself. I printed hundred page documents, read them, and tossed them. This was standard practice among all employees.

All these wasteful activities are cases where costs were reimbursable and made life marginally easier.

That those things were more expensive had nothing to do with quality of life.

Jared Diamond wrote about American consumption New York Times recently:

"Much American consumption is wasteful and contributes little or nothing to quality of life. For example, per capita oil consumption in Western Europe is about half of ours, yet Western Europe’s standard of living is higher by any reasonable criterion, including life expectancy, health, infant mortality, access to medical care, financial security after retirement, vacation time, quality of public schools and support for the arts. Ask yourself whether Americans’ wasteful use of gasoline contributes positively to any of those measures."

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/02/opinion/02diamond.html?pagewanted=2

RohitT
March 24, 2008 4:58 pm

@Steve - I wonder about your A+ / A- argument if the resulting outcome is nearly indistinguishable, like with your grade analogy if you get a 4.0 for both an A- and an A+, then its more efficient to go for the lower grade.

And to go along with Presh's comment about being wasteful, if there's no marginal benefit to people being an A+ level (that almost means their overworking / overqualified) then you're bound to end up with a lot of waste in the end, and last I checked, throwing things away doesn't help anyone out.

Got Something To Say?

Got Something To Say?

You Must Be Logged In To Comment
Not a Member? Brazen Careerist is a career management tool for next-generation professionals. Set up a free account today to comment on this post and start sharing your ideas. Learn more.
crimptopview.jpg
london.jpg
Flag_of_the_Czech_Republic.jpg
ggbridgesmall.jpg
Orange County logo.jpg

Grad School Zone

ScottShrum.jpg
Scott Shrum

This is the time of year when, every time the phone rings here at Veritas Prep HQ, there's a good chance it's an applicant calling to ask us if he should apply to business school in the third admissions round, or if he should wait until next year. The answer, as is the answer for most things in life, is "It depends."

Personal Branding

JM08.JPG
Jason Mollica

When I embarked on my blog journey last December, I thought of it as just an extension of who I was, professionally and personally. I also looked at the blog as a way of being creative. It’s become more than that to me and those of you that read this. My blog is now part of my personal brand.

Advantage Integrated Tale...
Senior Accountant
Booz Allen Hamilton Inc....
Contract Management Analy...
Experimentation Project M...
Automatic Data Processing...
Major Account Sales Repre...
Major Account Sales Repre...
X